Faith & anxiety
When Fear Makes God Hard to Recognize
Published on this site
When fear and doubt make God feel distant, Jesus walking on water offers perspective, practical reflection, and room for honest faith.
Sometimes the hardest part of a difficult season is wondering whether God is present in it.
You may believe he cares about you and still feel alone. You may pray regularly while wondering whether anyone is listening. You may know the right things to say about faith, yet find that those truths feel distant when the diagnosis arrives, the relationship becomes strained, or another uncertain week begins.
In those moments, fear can become the lens through which we interpret everything—including God.
The story of Jesus walking on water gives us a picture of this experience. The disciples are working against the wind, exhausted and unable to make easy progress. Jesus approaches them, but they don’t recognize him. They mistake his presence for another reason to be afraid.
There is something familiar about that.
They were struggling after doing what Jesus asked
Both Matthew and Mark tell us that Jesus directed the disciples to get into the boat and go ahead of him while he dismissed the crowd (Matthew 14:22; Mark 6:45).
They weren’t there because they ignored him.
That detail matters because difficulty can quickly become an accusation against ourselves:
“Maybe I made the wrong decision.”
“Maybe God is disappointed in me.”
“If I were following him correctly, this wouldn’t be so hard.”
Sometimes our choices do contribute to our problems, and honest reflection is appropriate. But hardship alone does not establish that we have done something wrong.
You can make a thoughtful career decision and encounter uncertainty. You can set a necessary boundary and experience conflict. You can begin counseling, practice healthier habits, and still have difficult days.
The disciples’ experience challenges the assumption that obedience should always feel reassuring. They followed Jesus’ direction and encountered a contrary wind.
These were capable people facing something they couldn’t control
At least four disciples—Peter, Andrew, James, and John—were working fishermen. Boats, nets, and the Sea of Galilee were familiar parts of their lives.
We don’t know the size of their particular boat. An ancient fishing boat recovered from the lake, dating to around Jesus’ time, measures approximately 27 feet long and 7½ feet wide. It offers a useful comparison for imagining the setting: a wooden working vessel exposed to the wind and waves.
Mark describes the disciples straining at the oars. Matthew describes the boat being battered by the waves. Both use forms of the Greek verb basanizō, a vivid word that can describe distress or severe strain.
Their experience and effort were real. So were their limits.
That can be difficult for capable people to accept. If you are accustomed to solving problems, you may respond to uncertainty by working harder, gathering more information, or trying to anticipate every possible outcome.
Those efforts can be useful. But when the situation remains beyond your control, you may begin to interpret your limitations as personal failure—or God’s absence.
The disciples were still rowing. They simply couldn’t make the wind cooperate.
Jesus saw them before they recognized him
Mark 6:48 says Jesus saw the disciples struggling.
From their position in the boat, they could not yet see what he was doing. From his position, they were already in view.
That distinction is worth sitting with.
Our awareness is limited. We can describe what we feel and what we can observe, but we cannot see the whole picture. The experience of feeling abandoned is painful; it does not, by itself, settle whether we have been abandoned.
This doesn’t mean we should pretend every difficult event is secretly pleasant or easy to explain. Some experiences involve genuine loss, injustice, and unanswered questions.
It does mean we can leave room for something beyond our immediate interpretation:
“I feel alone right now. I don’t yet know everything about this situation.”
That sentence acknowledges the feeling while keeping it from becoming the final verdict.
They mistook help for danger
When Jesus approaches during the fourth watch of the night—roughly 3 to 6 a.m.—the disciples think they are seeing a ghost. They cry out in fear.
The text doesn’t explain every reason for their mistake. They are in darkness, have been struggling for hours, and are encountering something far outside ordinary experience.
Still, the irony is clear: the person coming toward them is the person they most need, and they initially experience his arrival as a threat.
We can make similar interpretive mistakes in everyday life.
Consider a few hypothetical examples.
A strained relationship
After several tense days, your spouse says, “Can we talk tonight?”
You immediately anticipate criticism or rejection. By the time the conversation begins, you are defensive and prepared to argue.
But your spouse wants to acknowledge their own part in the conflict and ask for help reconnecting.
Fear has supplied an explanation before you have heard what they intend to say.
That doesn’t mean every difficult conversation is safe or constructive. It means your first prediction deserves to be checked against the actual interaction.
Financial uncertainty
A slow month at work creates understandable concern. You begin checking your accounts repeatedly and mentally rehearsing everything that could go wrong.
Meanwhile, a colleague offers a referral, your spouse wants to work through the budget with you, and there are practical steps available.
None of those things guarantees the outcome you want. But fear can make them feel insignificant because they don’t remove uncertainty immediately.
Within Christian faith, we can remain open to receiving ordinary help as an expression of God’s care. We don’t have to label every event a special message to recognize that support is present.
Shame after a setback
You return to a habit you wanted to change. Your conclusion is immediate:
“God must be tired of me.”
You stop praying, withdraw from supportive relationships, and spend several days criticizing yourself.
Yet the opportunity to tell the truth, receive care, and begin again remains available.
Shame can make an invitation to return feel like an announcement that you no longer belong.
Anxiety that continues despite prayer
You pray and still feel unsettled. You conclude that your faith must be inadequate or that God has not heard you.
But perhaps you are still able to ask for support, attend your appointment, care for your family, or take one difficult step.
Ongoing anxiety deserves care. Its presence does not automatically mean prayer failed or God withdrew.
The story reveals who Jesus is
It would be easy to turn this passage into a general lesson about thinking more positively. But the Gospel writers are doing something more substantial.
Jesus walks on the sea—an action that recalls Old Testament descriptions of God’s authority over the waters, including Job 9:8 and Psalm 77:19.
Mark also says Jesus intended to “pass by” the disciples. Many interpreters connect that language with accounts of God revealing himself to Moses and Elijah. On that reading, Jesus is making himself known.
Matthew’s account concludes with the disciples worshipping him and identifying him as God’s Son.
The question becomes: Who is this person approaching us?
Remembering Jesus’ identity gives Christian trust its foundation. We are learning to place our uncertainty in relationship with someone whose character has been revealed.
Peter’s fear—and Jesus’ response
Matthew includes Peter stepping out of the boat. When he notices the wind, he becomes afraid and begins to sink. He cries for rescue, and Jesus immediately reaches out and takes hold of him (Matthew 14:28–31).
Jesus addresses Peter’s doubt. He also helps him while he is doubting.
Both details matter.
We can take our patterns of fear seriously without concluding that fear makes us unreachable. Peter does not have to recover perfect composure before calling out. His frightened request is enough to express his need.
That offers a different way to pray:
“God, I’m scared, and I don’t know what to do.”
“I want to trust you, but I’m struggling.”
“Help me take the next step.”
Honesty can be part of faith.
How to make room for a fuller picture
When fear becomes consuming, try slowing down enough to examine what is happening.
First, name the situation and the feeling. “I haven’t heard back about the job, and I’m afraid.” Keep the observable circumstance distinct from your prediction about its meaning.
Next, notice the conclusion. Are you assuming rejection? Punishment? Abandonment? Are you treating uncertainty as proof that the worst outcome is coming?
Then, consider what else belongs in the picture. What support is available? What do you know about God’s character? What information is missing? What would a trusted person notice that you are overlooking?
Finally, choose one helpful action. Make the call. Have the conversation. Ask for assistance. Rest before making a major decision. Bring the concern into counseling or prayer.
You may still feel afraid while doing something wise.
Recognizing God’s presence doesn’t require feeling peaceful
This story ends with the wind stopping. Our own hardships do not always resolve so quickly.
We should be careful about promising someone that God’s presence means an immediate change in circumstances. Nor should we assume that recognizing his presence will eliminate every symptom of anxiety.
You can trust and tremble. You can pray and remain uncertain. You can accept help before you understand what the entire season will mean.
The disciples’ limited recognition did not prevent Jesus from seeing them. Their fear did not keep him from approaching.
When fear gets loud, it can help to ask:
“What might I be overlooking because I’m so focused on what could go wrong?”
The answer may be a practical resource, an available relationship, an invitation to be honest, or a truth about God that has become difficult to remember.
You don’t have to force certainty. You can begin by allowing your present feeling to be part of the picture, while making room for what you cannot yet see.
If anxiety, doubt, or shame is making daily life difficult, counseling can offer space to understand those patterns and practice responding differently. I work with adults in Dallas and Richardson, with Christian faith integrated according to your preferences.
Scripture and further reading
- Matthew 14:22–33
- Mark 6:45–52
- Job 9:8; Psalm 77:19; Exodus 33:18–23; 1 Kings 19:11–13.
- Shelley Wachsmann, “Ancient Seafaring on the Sea of Galilee”, for archaeological background on Galilean boats.
The everyday examples are hypothetical illustrations, not client stories.
← All articles